It has been a very hard year for Tucson area non-profits. In the Annual Arizona Illustrated "State of Giving" panel four community service providers discuss what they are doing to help the community during the holidays.

State of Giving 2009 panel

Included in the discussion are Major Peter Clack of the Salvation Army in Tucson, Bill Carnegie, president and CEO of the Community Food Bank, Richard White, executive director of American Red Cross, Southern Arizona Chapter and Lisa Humenik, president and CEO of the Volunteer Center of Southern Arizona.